Asphalt Shingle Brands and Comparison: The Ultimate Guide

Spread the love
Asphalt Shingle Brands and Comparison: The Ultimate Guide

Introduction

Asphalt shingles are a popular roofing material, known for their affordability, durability, and variety. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the different types of asphalt shingles, explore the top brands in the market, and provide an in-depth comparison to help you choose the best shingles for your roofing needs.

Types and Categories

Organic Asphalt Shingles

Organic asphalt shingles are composed of a paper base that is saturated with asphalt to make them waterproof. These shingles are then coated with adhesive asphalt and embedded with ceramic granules. Advantages: Heavier and more durable, good performance in cold weather. Disadvantages: Prone to warping over time, less fire-resistant compared to fiberglass shingles. These were very common shingles 20 years ago but they are no longer made. You probably have seen them on older roofs today.

Fiberglass Asphalt Shingles

Fiberglass shingles have a fiberglass mat at their core, which is coated with asphalt and topped with ceramic granules. Advantages: Lightweight, more fire-resistant, longer lifespan. Disadvantages: Can be brittle and prone to cracking in extreme cold.

Architectural Asphalt Shingles

Also known as laminated or dimensional shingles, these are premium products that have a more sophisticated appearance. Advantages: Enhanced aesthetic appeal, better wind resistance, longer warranties. Disadvantages: Higher cost compared to 3-tab shingles.

3-Tab Asphalt Shingles

These are the most basic and economical shingles, featuring three tabs on each strip. Advantages: Affordable, easy to install, good for budget-conscious projects. Disadvantages: Less durable, shorter lifespan.

Top Asphalt Shingle Brands

GAF

Brand History and Overview: GAF is one of the largest roofing manufacturers in North America, known for its wide range of high-quality roofing products. Product Lineup: Includes Timberline, Glenwood, and Royal Sovereign shingles. Key Features and Innovations: Advanced Protection Shingle technology, StainGuard protection. Customer Reviews and Feedback: Generally positive reviews, praised for durability and aesthetic appeal.

Owens Corning

Brand History and Overview: A leading innovator in roofing materials, Owens Corning offers a variety of shingles that cater to different needs. Product Lineup: Includes Duration, Oakridge, and Supreme shingles. Key Features and Innovations: SureNail Technology, TruDefinition color platform. Customer Reviews and Feedback: Highly rated for impact resistance and overall quality.

CertainTeed

Brand History and Overview: Known for its comprehensive range of roofing solutions, CertainTeed offers premium shingles with extensive warranty options. Product Lineup: Includes Landmark, Presidential, and XT 25 shingles. Key Features and Innovations: StreakFighter algae resistance, QuadraBond adhesive. Customer Reviews and Feedback: Acclaimed for durability and customer support.

TAMKO

Brand History and Overview: TAMKO has been providing roofing products for over 75 years, known for their reliability and performance. Product Lineup: Includes Heritage, Elite Glass-Seal, and MetalWorks shingles. Key Features and Innovations: TAMKO’s distinct granule mix, advanced sealants. Customer Reviews and Feedback: Positive feedback for affordability and ease of installation.

Atlas Roofing

Brand History and Overview: Atlas Roofing offers innovative and cost-effective roofing solutions, with a focus on sustainability. Product Lineup: Includes Pinnacle Pristine, StormMaster, and Legend shingles. Key Features and Innovations: Scotchgard Protector, Core4 Enhanced Polymer Technology. Customer Reviews and Feedback: High ratings for algae resistance and longevity.

Detailed Brand Comparison

Durability and Lifespan

  • GAF vs. Owens Corning: Both brands offer long-lasting shingles with advanced protection features. GAF’s Timberline series and Owens Corning’s Duration shingles are noted for their exceptional durability.
  • CertainTeed vs. TAMKO: CertainTeed’s Landmark shingles typically have longer lifespans compared to TAMKO’s Heritage series, due to higher quality materials and better manufacturing processes.
  • Atlas Roofing vs. Others: Atlas’s Pinnacle Pristine shingles are designed for longevity with their advanced polymer technology, making them comparable to top-tier brands like GAF and CertainTeed.

Weather Resistance

  • GAF vs. CertainTeed: Both brands offer excellent weather resistance, but CertainTeed’s QuadraBond adhesive provides an edge in extreme conditions.
  • Owens Corning vs. Atlas Roofing: Owens Corning’s SureNail Technology offers superior wind resistance, while Atlas’s StormMaster shingles are renowned for their impact resistance.
  • TAMKO vs. Others: TAMKO’s shingles perform well in moderate climates but may not offer the same level of protection in extreme weather as brands like GAF and Owens Corning.

Aesthetic Appeal

  • Architectural Shingles Comparison: GAF’s Glenwood, Owens Corning’s Duration Designer, and CertainTeed’s Presidential shingles all offer high-end, multi-dimensional looks that enhance curb appeal.
  • Color Variety and Customization Options: Owens Corning’s TruDefinition color platform offers the widest range of colors, followed by GAF and CertainTeed.

Installation Process

  • Ease of Installation for Each Brand: GAF and Owens Corning shingles are known for their straightforward installation processes, often preferred by contractors for their ease of use.
  • Recommended Contractors and Services: Many top brands provide certified contractor programs to ensure proper installation and warranty coverage.

Cost Comparison

Price Range of Different Brands

  • GAF Pricing: Timberline shingles range from $90 to $120 per square.
  • Owens Corning Pricing: Duration shingles typically cost between $80 and $110 per square.
  • CertainTeed Pricing: Landmark shingles are priced from $95 to $125 per square.
  • TAMKO Pricing: Heritage shingles range from $75 to $100 per square.
  • Atlas Roofing Pricing: Pinnacle Pristine shingles cost between $85 and $115 per square.

Cost-Effectiveness

  • Long-Term Value: Brands like CertainTeed and GAF offer better long-term value due to their higher durability and extensive warranty options.
  • Warranty and Guarantees: Most brands provide warranties ranging from 25 years to lifetime, with CertainTeed and GAF offering some of the most comprehensive coverage.

Environmental Impact

Sustainable Practices

  • GAF’s Eco-Friendly Initiatives: GAF focuses on sustainability through energy-efficient products and recycling programs.
  • Owens Corning’s Sustainability Efforts: Owens Corning has a strong commitment to reducing environmental impact through its EcoTouch insulation and shingle recycling.
  • CertainTeed’s Green Practices: CertainTeed emphasizes eco-friendly manufacturing and waste reduction.
  • TAMKO’s Environmental Contributions: TAMKO participates in recycling and reducing industrial waste.
  • Atlas Roofing’s Eco-Friendly Measures: Atlas uses recycled materials in their products and promotes sustainability initiatives.

Recyclability of Asphalt Shingles

  • Benefits of Recycling: Recycling asphalt shingles reduces landfill waste and conserves natural resources.
  • Process of Recycling Asphalt Shingles: Shingles are ground up and reused in road construction and other applications.

Performance in Various Climates

Hot and Dry Climates

  • Best Brands for Hot Weather: GAF’s Timberline Cool Series and CertainTeed’s Solaris shingles are designed to reflect more sunlight and reduce heat absorption.
  • Performance Metrics: These shingles can significantly lower cooling costs and extend roof lifespan.

Cold and Wet Climates

  • Best Brands for Cold Weather: Owens Corning’s Duration and CertainTeed’s NorthGate shingles perform well in cold climates due to their flexibility and resistance to cracking.
  • Performance Metrics: These shingles maintain their integrity and prevent ice dam formation.

Coastal Areas

  • Best Brands for Coastal Conditions: Atlas’s Pinnacle Pristine and CertainTeed’s Landmark shingles offer excellent resistance to salt spray and high winds.
  • Performance Metrics: High wind ratings and corrosion-resistant features make these brands ideal for coastal applications.

Common Problems and Solutions

Algae and Mold Resistance

  • Effective Brands and Products: Atlas’s Pinnacle Pristine shingles with Scotchgard Protector and GAF’s Timberline series with StainGuard are top choices for algae resistance.
  • Maintenance Tips: Regular roof cleaning and proper ventilation can prevent algae and mold growth.

Wind Resistance

  • Comparison of Wind Ratings: GAF and Owens Corning offer shingles with wind ratings up to 130 mph, making them suitable for high-wind areas.
  • Best Brands for High Wind Areas: CertainTeed’s Landmark and Owens Corning’s Duration shingles are among the best for wind resistance.

Impact Resistance

  • Hail and Debris Impact Ratings: Owens Corning’s Duration Storm and Atlas’s StormMaster shingles are designed to withstand severe impact.
  • Leading Brands for Impact Resistance: These brands offer the highest ratings for impact resistance, making them ideal for hail-prone regions.

Customer Support and Service

Brand Warranty Comparison

  • Types of Warranties Offered: Lifetime warranties are common among top brands, with CertainTeed and GAF offering some of the most comprehensive coverage.
  • Claim Process and Customer Experience: Brands like Owens Corning and CertainTeed are praised for their efficient and supportive claim processes.

Availability and Distribution

  • Regional Availability: Most top brands have widespread availability across North America, with certain products being region-specific.
  • Online Purchasing Options: Many brands offer online purchasing through their websites or third-party retailers.

Expert Insights

Roofing Contractors’ Opinions

  • Preferred Brands by Professionals: GAF and Owens Corning are frequently recommended by roofing contractors for their reliability and ease of installation.
  • Insights on Installation and Maintenance: Contractors highlight the importance of following manufacturer guidelines to ensure warranty coverage and long-term performance.

Consumer Reports and Ratings

  • Analysis of Consumer Satisfaction: Consumer reports often rate GAF and Owens Corning highly for overall satisfaction, with CertainTeed also receiving positive feedback.
  • Common Praise and Complaints: Durability, aesthetic appeal, and warranty coverage are commonly praised, while cost and availability can be points of contention.

Personal Stories and Case Studies

Real-Life Success Stories

  • Homeowner Testimonials: Many homeowners share positive experiences with GAF and CertainTeed shingles, noting improvements in home appearance and energy efficiency.
  • Before and After Comparisons: Visual comparisons show significant upgrades in curb appeal and roof integrity after switching to high-quality shingles.

Problematic Installations

  • Case Studies of Failures and Solutions: Issues such as improper installation or choosing the wrong type of shingle are highlighted, with solutions including hiring certified contractors and selecting suitable products for the local climate.
  • Lessons Learned from Installation Issues: Emphasizes the importance of professional installation and proper maintenance to avoid common roofing problems.

Conclusion

In conclusion, choosing the right asphalt shingle brand involves considering factors such as durability, weather resistance, cost, and aesthetic appeal. Brands like GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed consistently rank high in these categories, offering a range of products to suit different needs and climates. By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each brand, homeowners can make an informed decision that ensures the longevity and performance of their roof.